Reading and Milton Keynes Dons meet on Tuesday night at the Select Car Leasing Stadium in the EFL Trophy’s Southern Group D, with both sides still harbouring hopes of reaching the knockout stage.
Reading sit second in the group after a spirited 3-1 comeback win over West Ham’s U21s, having earlier suffered a narrow 3-2 loss to Swindon. Victory here would almost guarantee progression for Noel Hunt’s side, who have looked far livelier in cup competition than in the league.
In League One, Reading remain 19th with 10 points from 10 games and rank 18th for xPTS (10.6). Their underlying data shows a team struggling to control games, averaging 1.01 non-penalty xG for and 1.15 against per match.
However, cup performances have been brighter, with Hunt using the competition to blend academy talent with senior regulars. The mood around the club has steadied slightly after a run of battling displays, though defensive lapses continue to cost them.
MK Dons, meanwhile, come in with momentum from League Two, sitting sixth with 18 points from 11 matches. Their xPTS of 14.8 and xG ratio of 56% reflect one of the division’s more balanced attacking units.
They have scored in every away game this season and boast 19 league goals already, though their EFL Trophy campaign has been far less convincing. A heavy defeat to West Ham’s U21s (5-1) leave them bottom of the group. Paul Warne’s side have shown attacking intent but little control, meaning they will likely need to be bold here to keep qualification hopes alive.
How the bookies view it: No odds available
Head to Head: Finely Balanced
These sides have met five times in competitive fixtures, and the head-to-head record is finely balanced. Reading have one win, MK Dons one, and two meetings have ended level, with a combined goal difference of 4-4.
The most recent encounter came in the FA Cup last season, when Reading edged a lively 3-2 contest at the Select Car Leasing Stadium. It was a game that reflected both teams’ attacking approach, with Reading twice coming from behind before sealing victory in the closing stages. That win extended their unbeaten home record against the Dons to three matches.
Their previous meetings came during MK Dons’ short spell in the Championship in 2015-16. The August 2015 clash ended goalless at Reading, while the return fixture in Milton Keynes was decided by a single goal, with MK Dons winning 1-0 courtesy of a first-half strike. The only other competitive meeting was a 1-1 draw in the 2016 League Cup, when Reading progressed on penalties after a cagey 90 minutes.
Across the five fixtures, margins have always been narrow. None have been decided by more than one goal, and both teams have scored in three of the last four. The overall pattern suggests a fairly even rivalry, with Reading’s greater home consistency balanced by MK Dons’ competitiveness in the reverse fixtures.
Players to watch: Mendez-Laing to be a threat
Nathaniel Mendez-Laing looks a strong candidate for a shot-on-target or anytime scorer bet against Reading. The winger has been central to MK Dons’ attacking play this season, starting 10 of their 11 league games and playing over 800 minutes. He has produced 14 shots with eight on target, converting at a 57% accuracy rate, and has scored twice in his last five appearances.
His recent form is encouraging, with goals in wins over Newport and Gillingham, while he also created one in the 5-0 victory against Cheltenham. Mendez-Laing’s pace and willingness to cut inside from the right makes him a constant threat, particularly against a Reading side that have managed just one clean sheet in ten League One games and have conceded in both EFL Trophy outings.
Given MK Dons’ attacking intent and Mendez-Laing’s shot consistency, he looks well priced for at least one effort on target and offers strong value in the anytime goal scorer market.
Predicted line-ups
Reading (4-3-3): Stevens; Abrefa, Dorsett, Stickland, Jacob; Savage, Wing, Elliott; Ritchie, O'Mahony, Ehibhatiomhan
MK Dons (4-3-3):Trueman; Offord, Tripp, Maguire, Mellish; Gibley, Kelly, Crowley; Leko, Paterson, Mendez-Laing
Anything else catch the eye?
The numbers strongly point to another high-scoring contest between Reading and MK Dons. Both sides have been involved in open matches throughout the EFL Trophy, with Reading’s two group fixtures producing a total of nine goals and MK Dons’ pair yielding six.
Reading’s attacking output in this competition has been far stronger than in League One. They have averaged over 14 shots per game and hit the target on at least six occasions in both matches, showing a greater willingness to press and attack in numbers. Their opponents, however, continue to create against them. Reading have conceded in nine of their last ten games across all competitions and have managed just one clean sheet all season.
MK Dons’ data tells a similar story. Their League Two matches have gone over 2.5 goals in 55% of cases, and they have scored in every away fixture. They rank eighth in their division for xPTS (14.75) and average 1.10 non-penalty xG per match. Defensively, they allow 0.86 xGA, but that figure has ballooned in this competition, conceding five times in their only outing.
Add in the shot profiles and the case strengthens further. MK Dons average 12.3 shots and 4.5 on target per league match, while Reading’s EFL Trophy games have averaged four big chances per 90 minutes. Both sides favour front-foot football and both defences leak opportunities. With the group standings encouraging a positive approach, this fixture has all the signs of another end-to-end encounter. Over 2.5 goals looks the standout play.
GambleAware