A South Yorkshire derby takes centre stage at Oakwell on Friday, with Barnsley facing Sheffield Wednesday in League One at 20:00. The clubs approach the contest in contrasting circumstances, with the hosts desperate to arrest their decline and the visitors attempting to establish themselves among the promotion contenders.
Barnsley's difficult campaign continued with a 2-1 defeat at Wigan Athletic on Saturday. Fraser Murray opened the scoring before Cameron McGeehan equalised shortly after half-time, but Jensen Weir headed the winner in the 75th minute. The result represented Barnsley's fifth defeat in six league matches.
Sheffield Wednesday enjoyed a more productive weekend, beating Plymouth Argyle 3-0 in Dave Challinor's first league match as manager. Billy Mitchell broke the deadlock shortly before half-time, with Davis Keillor-Dunn and Di'Shon Bernard adding late goals after the visitors had initially looked the stronger side.
The victory lifted Wednesday to fifth, six points behind the automatic promotion places. Challinor emphasised the importance of outworking opponents and building a winning sequence, with his immediate challenge being to reproduce that performance away from Hillsborough.
Bernard's return was another positive development. The defender completed 90 minutes following a lengthy absence through injury and marked the occasion with a goal, providing Wednesday with an additional option at the back.
How the bookies view it
Sheffield Wednesday are favourites at 13/10, representing an implied probability of 43.5%. Barnsley are priced at 2/1, equivalent to 33.3%, while the draw is available at 3/1, giving it a 25% implied probability.
The bookmakers expect an entertaining encounter, with over 2.5 goals offered at 1/2 and under 2.5 priced at 13/8. Both teams to score Yes is available at 5/11, while No is offered at 7/4.
Head to head: Wednesday won at Wembley
The most recent meeting between these clubs came in the 2023 League One play-off final at Wembley, when Wednesday secured promotion with a 1-0 victory after extra time.
Barnsley had enjoyed greater success during the regular season, winning 2-0 at Hillsborough before recording a 4-2 victory in the return fixture at Oakwell.
The Reds have won three of the previous five encounters, with Wednesday taking the other two. Three of those matches produced goals at both ends, and the same number featured at least three goals.
Their most recent draw came in February 2020, when the sides shared a 1-1 result.
Predicted lineups
Barnsley (4-2-3-1): Slicker; Okedina, Gale, Kay, Larkeche; Connell, Johnson; Yoganathan, McGeehan, Cleary; Kirk.
Sheffield Wednesday (3-4-2-1): Lumley; Bernard, Cooper, Swinkels; Valery, Mitchell, Slattery, Lowe; Keillor-Dunn, Bannan; Heskey.
Player to watch: Jamal Lowe main attacking threat for the Owls
Jamal Lowe has established himself as one of Sheffield Wednesday's principal attacking threats, with seven goals from 13 League One appearances.
The forward has accumulated 8.11 xG from 40 shots, including 17 efforts on target. His expected-goals figure indicates that he has been receiving opportunities in dangerous positions, even though his finishing return sits slightly below expectation.
Lowe also contributes to Wednesday's attacking build-up, having created 17 chances and registered 0.84 xA. His ability to find shooting positions should be particularly important against opponents who have struggled to prevent chances inside their own defensive third.
Anything else catch the eye?
Sheffield Wednesday to win at 13/10 is the preferred selection, although the underlying numbers reveal weaknesses in both teams. Barnsley have collected nine points from 13 league matches, despite accumulating 17.3 xPTS. That difference suggests their results have been significantly worse than their expected performances.
The problems are particularly evident at Oakwell, where they have won once in six league fixtures, drawing twice and losing three. They have scored six goals and conceded 11, failing to keep a clean sheet.
Their attacking output remains respectable, averaging 1.77 xG and 18.17 shots per home match. The greater concern is their defensive record, with opponents generating 2.13 xGA per fixture. Their recent meeting with Oxford United highlighted those difficulties. Although Barnsley secured a 1-1 draw, the visitors produced 3.15 xG from 35 attempts, compared with the hosts' 1.29 xG from 11 shots.
Wednesday's overall record is considerably stronger, with 23 points from 14 league matches. They average 1.85 xG and 1.44 xGA, producing a positive expected-goals difference of 0.41 per fixture.
The Owls have also won three of their six away matches, drawing once and losing twice. Their attacking average of 1.74 xG on the road provides encouragement against a defence allowing regular opportunities.
There is an important counterargument. Wednesday have failed to score in three of their last four away fixtures, while their recent travelling figures have deteriorated to 1.25 xG and 2.04 xGA.
Those numbers make this a less straightforward selection than the league standings suggest. Barnsley possess enough attacking quality to cause problems, particularly if Wednesday continue conceding chances at their recent rate.
The goals markets are worth considering. Five of Barnsley's six home matches have seen both teams score, while four of Wednesday's six away fixtures have featured over 2.5 goals. Neither market offers the same balance of price and supporting evidence as the away victory.
Wednesday's stronger overall attacking process, superior points return and opportunity to build momentum under their new manager give them the advantage. Barnsley's defensive problems provide the clearest route to success, making Sheffield Wednesday to win at 13/10 the preferred bet.
GambleAware